Academics is not polemics with glasses on.I warned him. (Link)
- ersatz quotation (2013)
He became incensed. (Link)
Now the subject of the conversation is in limbo. (Link)
"Comfort Women, Military Prostitution and Human Trafficking" was not a bad study. It was not any kind of study at all.
My guess: this is going to become a rather interesting intellectual contretemps.
In his writing, the author of the now dangling article did get one thing right: I am pompous.
Kind of can't give it up either. Probably should. Can't.
Hat tip to reader Toyotsu for the link.
See now http://www.japanfpo.org/2013/03/dogmatism-and-compromise-part-ii.html
ReplyDeleteTo be honest, his response seems a lot more convincing than your criticism.
ReplyDeleteToo bad we can't read the offending article anymore...
Anonymous -
ReplyDeleteAgreed. Then again, I just quickly set down some objections from a cursory scan of the document. A serious look at the text would have consumed a day -- and there are much better ways of spending a day.
If you really want to read the essay, there is always:
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:gBlhhHFs7mcJ:www.japanesestudies.org.uk/ejcjs/vol12/iss3/gray.html+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=jp